One of the more challenging areas of legal malpractice occurs when an expected beneficiary of a will or trust is disinherited. Was that the result of an error by the lawyer? That raises further issues. Why should the expected beneficiary (“I thought I was going to inherit Blackacre”) have a right to sue a lawyer for legal malpractice when he did not hire the lawyer himself? The lawyer is hired by the testator. These are hard questions and a New Jersey case, Christakos v. Boyadis, 262 N.J. 447, 348 A.3d 966 (2026) decided earlier this year, has addressed them.
The central question in Christakos is whether a lawyer who drafts a will owes a duty of care to a non-client relative who expected to inherit, so that the relative can sue the lawyer for malpractice. The Court held that New Jersey decides that question under Restatement (Third) of the Law Governing Lawyers § 51(2) and (3). It also held that the testators’ niece, Helen Christakos, could not meet either subsection. (348 A.3d at 970, 979.) The case’s holding has the effect of limiting the lawyer’s liability to the non-client.
Chicago Legal Malpractice Lawyer Blog




