The case is captioned Robert Iuffues Webb II v. Janice Holmes, 2018 IL App (3d) 170167. Webb, who is not licensed to practice law, alleged that he had assisted Holmes with certain federal litigation. It is not clear exactly what the federal litigation involved. He alleged that he entered into an…
Chicago Legal Malpractice Lawyer Blog
New York District Court Holds That Plaintiff Adequately Alleged that Lawyer Missed Statute of Limitations on Employment Claims
The case is Alexander Prout v. Anne C. Vladeck & Vladeck, Raskin & Clark, P.C., 18 CV 260 (S.D. New York June 10, 2018). Prout alleged that he retained Vladeck to represent him in connection with claims against his former employer, Invesco. He further alleged that Vladeck advised him to…
Condominium Owner Cannot Sue The Condominium Association’s Lawyer
One issue that arises frequently in legal malpractice cases is – to whom does the lawyer owe a duty? Here, a condominium owner sued the lawyer for the condominium association for breach of contract. The court dismissed the case and the Colorado Supreme Court affirmed the dismissal. The Colorado Supreme…
Proximate Causation Defeats Divorce Malpractice Claim
The case is captioned William Molim Siu v. The Cavanagh Law Firm, 1-CA-CV 17-0601 (Arizona Court of Appeals). Siu sued his former lawyer for alleged negligence in handling Siu’s divorce case. The divorce case was heard by an Arbitrator who ruled that certain property owned by Siu before the marriage became…
New Jersey Court Shoots Down Legal Malpractice Claim Asserted As A Defense to A Fee Claim
One question which comes up frequently is whether a client can sue his former lawyer for legal malpractice based on what the client believes is an inflated legal bill. A legal fee dispute is essentially a breach of contract case filed by the lawyer against the former client. Here the…
Kentucky Court of Appeals Affirms Dismissal of Legal Malpractice Lawsuit Against Executor of Estate
An estate hired a lawyer to act as the co-executor of the estate. The lawyer was paid on a percentage basis – 3% of the gross amount of the Estate. (In Illinois this type of payment arrangement is illegal. However, in Kentucky is it is perfectly legal). Of note is…
Lawyers Burned By Fee Shifting Clause They Inserted in Engagement Letter
The law firm inserted a fee-shifting clause in its retainer agreement, providing that the “prevailing party” was entitled to attorney fees. The text of the clause is as follows: “”In the event of a dispute between you and the firm regarding any matters relating to the retention . . ., the prevailing party shall be…
Successor Counsel Had An Opportunity To Fix The Lawyer’s Error – So No Legal Malpractice Claim For Client
Sometimes things get missed or lost in the shuffle when clients change lawyers. It is often difficult to get the new lawyer up to speed in time to get a case ready for dispositive motions or trial. When I see that the client had numerous lawyers involved in a case, that…
Repeat Post – Witness Who Testified Against Lawyer in Disciplinary Hearing Immune From Defamation Claim
The case is Bar Counsel v. Peter Farber, SJC 11171 (Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court). This post is a repeat from a few years ago. I regard the opinion highly and think every lawyer should read it before taking any action adverse to an unhappy client. Farber was the subject of…
Think Carefully Before Writing a book about a case you prosecuted.
The Board of Professional Responsibility of the Tennessee Supreme Court has censured a prosecutor who obtained the conviction of three defendants in a murder case. While appeals were pending, the prosecutor wrote a book about the prosecution. Two of the Defendants filed motions for a new trial, alleging that the…