I asked Chat GPT what “Legal Malpractice” is. It produced the following overview, which I then edited. Legal malpractice refers to a situation in which an attorney fails to perform his duties to a client in a competent and ethical manner, resulting in harm or financial loss to the client.…
Chicago Legal Malpractice Lawyer Blog
Texas Revives A Legal Malpractice Claim Based on A Failure to Seek and Collect Damages
The Supreme Court of Texas has issued an opinion in USA Lending Group, Inc. v. Winstead, P.C., 669 S.W.3d 195 (2023). In this case the client sued its former law firm for failing to request damages in a default judgment motion. USA Lending hired the law firm to sue its…
Failure to Introduce Relevant Evidence Leads to Malpractice Award
In Paldino v. Johnson, 2023 Ohio 1947, Ohio Court of Appeals, 11th Appellate District 2023, the appellate court affirmed a legal malpractice verdict in favor of the plaintiff for a modest sum of money. Plaintiff hired a lawyer to assist him in dividing a parcel of property he owned with…
Plaintiff’s Complaint Dismissed For Failure to Allege Case-Within-A-Case
Buchanan v. Law Offices of Sheldon E. Green, P.C., 2023 NY Slip Op 1980 (New York Appellate Division, 2nd Department 2023), appears to be a slam dunk legal malpractice case but it was dismissed. Why? Because the plaintiff failed to plausibly allege that she would have won the underlying case.…
Six Month Statute of Limitations Bars Claims Against Estate Attorneys
The Illinois statute of limitations period governing legal malpractice cases is normally two years. The plaintiff has two years from the discovery of the injury to file suit. Illinois has another provision in the statute, which often protects lawyers involved in estate planning. 5/13-214.3(d) provides that: When the injury caused…
Lawyer Who Represented LLC Owed No Duty To Its Manager
The Illinois Appellate court recently affirmed a grant of summary judgment in the case captioned Requet v. Stengel, Bailey & Robertson, 2023 IL App (3d) 210203-U. The opinion is unpublished, but it is worth reading. Requet was the managing member of PVY Development, an LLC engaged in developing and selling…
Former Superintendent of Schools Cannot Recover For Legal Malpractice
One of the persistent and more difficult challenges in legal malpractice cases is proving that the client would have won the underlying case but for the negligence of the lawyer. This is known as but/for causation or proximate causation. In this case the plaintiff was a superintendent of a school…
New York Court Dismisses Legal Malpractice Claims Against Law Firm
In Mid-City Electrical Corporation v. Peckar & Abramson, 2023 NY Slip Op 1085, the New York Appellate Division, Second Department affirmed the dismissal of legal malpractice claims against company attorneys. First, the court ruled that the owners of Mid-City were not clients of Peckar & Abramson because they were not…
Anti-Assignment Rule Defeats Malpractice Claim
One of the more obscure rules in the world of legal malpractice is that legal malpractice claims cannot be assigned. The lawyer-client relationship is one of “privity.” It is a direct relationship between the client and the lawyer. Sometimes in litigation, one party requests that the other party assign to…
Failing to Sue All Tortfeasors States A Claim For Legal Malpractice
In Julio Chicas v. Christopher J. Cassar, et al, No. 2023 NY Slip Op 00202, Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York, Second Department, the plaintiff sued for malpractice claiming that the lawyer defendants failed to sue a tortfeasor. The case was dismissed at the trial level, but the…